Bimbo Banter

Just Rogue Engineers? Reminder of the Webster Way

  • Crisis
  • October 9, 2015
  • by Merrie Spaeth

2013 volkswagen-jetta-turbo-hybrid-blue-logo

Volkswagen of America Inc. has decided to hang its future on the word “rogue.” It’s a bad choice. They should fire the lawyer or PR firm advising it.

Rogue is Volkswagen’s explanation—and excuse—for the global debacle over the discovery that VW engineered its diesel cars to cheat emissions tests; the software turned on the proper filters during testing and off once the tests completed. Who was responsible? Apparently, just “rogue” engineers acting on their own.

It’s a mistake because it’s not believable that such a massive design strategy was a dark secret known only to a handful of engineers. It’s not believable because it’s not how engineers think. To accept that explanation requires that we believe that VW management is clueless and has no leadership philosophy.

My daughter (who also happens to be an engineer) says I endlessly repeat this story, but it’s appropriate here. I call it the Webster Way:  When I was chosen as a White House Fellow and assigned to the FBI, I asked the director, Judge William Webster, to explain my job as a Special Assistant. “Your job,” he said, “is to make sure I hear the things people think I don’t want to hear or that they don’t want me to hear.” This is a key requirement of leadership, particularly in the C-suite. 

So, which is it VW? Do you have a secluded corner where a few engineers plotted to cost the company billions – or did you fail to communicate the Webster Way?

You May Also Like

Christopher ruddy

The Definition of a Friend

Christopher Ruddy, the chief executive of NewsMax, appeared on PBS Monday night and was described as a “friend” of President Trump’s. He dropped the bombshell that the president was considering firing Robert Mueller, the just-appointed Special Counsel, charged… more 


The Comedian Who Cried Trump

“He broke me,” sobbed so-called comedian Kathy Griffin reacting to the virtually universal condemnation of her stunt of holding up a severed bloodied (plastic) head of President Donald Trump. In the resulting outcry, CNN announced Griffin would not… more 


Setting the Stage: The First Comment

Setting the stage, or more accurately, setting expectations is imperative in crisis management. The initial findings are rarely confirmed and your spokesperson should choose a response that implies the process is fluid. We call this the first comment… more 

Back to Top